flexiblefullpage - default
interstitial1 - interstitial
Currently Reading

How Home Improvement Companies Sell Today

billboard -
Home Improvement

How Home Improvement Companies Sell Today

Four replacement contractors reveal their sales processes and what’s changed since before COVID

By Drew Barto December 6, 2022
home improvement sales
This article first appeared in the November/December 2022 issue of Pro Remodeler.

Many factors stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in contractors abruptly adjusting their sales processes to meet new customer demands.

But have those requests—such as virtual consultations and quicker turnarounds on prices—continued now that business is mostly back to normal?

To find that answer, I spoke to four successful replacement contractors to gain insight into their sales processes and to find out if they’ve made any adjustments. Here’s what they had to say.


10% of Appointments Are Virtual With No Drop in Closing Percentage

home improvement ian foltz

Ian Foltz, Vice President

American Remodeling Enterprises

Schuylkill Haven, Pa.


“We leave a one-year price as advertised, and then we have an initial consultation offer, which includes a discount for doing business with us that night. The average appointment is 60 minutes for epoxy floors and up to two hours for roofing and windows.

Since March 2020, some customers want everything yesterday and they expect a quick turnaround when it comes to getting pricing and having the products installed.

As a mentor once told me, it’s not the big that eats the small, it’s the fast that eats the slow. If you’re not able to pivot and adjust your business model, then you will be in trouble.

There will always be in-home selling, but there’s going to be a percentage of the population who won’t accept that. For the customer who wants a price over the phone—about 10% of our appointments—we turn them over to one of our virtual sales specialists who reviews our product features, benefits, and pricing over a Google meeting. Our closing percentage is about the same in a virtual setting as it is in the home.”




Customer Satisfaction Increased by 15% With Improved Communication

graboyes windowsMontana Graboyes, Executive Vice President

Graboyes Window & Door

East Norriton, Pa.


“We don’t push the one-call close because I think that’s antithetical to what people want these days. Customers don’t want to be bullied into something—they want to be guided and helped. But unless there’s something uber-custom, we give pricing on our first visit.

We spend about 60 to 90 minutes in the home. We offer a slight discount to customers who purchase that day because that cuts down on administrative costs and gives our advisors more opportunities to visit new customers. Ninety-seven percent of the jobs we sell close within a 21-day window.

Early in the pandemic, we turned our conference room into a virtual presentation studio. We would demonstrate the samples as if we were in the home. But our customers stopped wanting that.

The biggest change we’ve seen is in managing new customer expectations from the night we sell all the way through installation. We’ve created a position in our company called the Customer Concierge whose job is to communicate with customers—good, bad, or ugly—every two weeks. As a result, our customer satisfaction has gone up by 15%.”



Closing More Sales by Eliminating the “Buy Today” Discount

contract exteriors home improvementRandy Hann, Owner

Contract Exteriors

Myrtle Beach and Charleston, S.C.


“I have friends who have moved to a one-call sales approach because they were negatively impacted by customer demand for shorter presentations. Our core customers are older, so we’re not seeing that.

We still do a two-step sales process. The first visit lasts about an hour. The second visit can last up to two hours if the customer is moving forward.

We’re not getting pushback on the two-step process upfront, but occasionally a customer wants the pricing emailed in lieu of a second visit. In those cases, we’ll schedule a phone call to discuss the proposal and email it to them while on the call.

The biggest thing we’ve changed is the “buy today” discount. We went the opposite of everyone I’ve talked to. Our discount is good for three days, not just for the day we give the price.

Initially, this new approach threw off the sales team. But now they realize they’re closing more sales with some follow-up. Customers often call us before we follow up to say they want to move forward and receive the discount.”



Two-Step Sales Process with Option for Virtual Second Visit

alco products home improvementJesse Kreisman, Vice President

Alco Products, Inc.

Bethesda, Md.


“While we’ll still quote some smaller projects in one visit, many of the projects we’re taking on now are more complex. So, a lot of our projects require two visits with the homeowners, rather than a one-call close.

The first visit is a needs assessment where we find out what problem the customer has and how we can solve it. Then, we prepare a proposal with a couple of options and schedule a second visit within five to 10 days of the first.

Where we differ from most one-call close companies is that we’re not going into the home with one option. We have multiple product lines and want to make sure the customer sees what they’re buying.

I firmly believe you have to be out to the home to see the project before giving a price, but I don’t have an issue if it’s easier for a client to do the second visit virtually. Even if COVID hadn’t happened, virtual meetings were going to become a part of our industry. I think most people still want physical interaction with a product, but you have to be willing to adapt.”





written by

Drew Barto

Drew Barto is director of home improvement for Pro Remodeler. He most recently served as the Director of Marketing at Energy Swing Windows in Pittsburgh. Contact him at dbarto@sgcmail.com or 412-607-7820.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
leaderboard2 - default

Related Stories

How Contractors Can Determine Lead Value

On this episode of Rock Stars of Remodeling, Builder Prime Founder and CEO Jonathan Weinberg reveals how contractors can effectively determine the value of each lead to their business, and why they must do so

24 Marketing Tips for Home Improvement Contractors in 2024

Quick-hitting advice on how contractors can increase and enhance lead flow in 2024

Rising Financing Fees to Impact Home Improvement Industry

NEWPRO Home Solutions COO shares his expert insight on the challenges facing the home improvement industry in 2024 for Pro Remodeler's Thought Leader predictions series

Presidential Election Will Create Uncertainty for Consumers

PJ Fitzpatrick CEO reveals his predictions and advice for the home improvement industry in 2024 for Pro Remodeler's Thought Leader predictions series

Discover Innovative Ways to Market and Tell Your Story

Leaf Home Chief Sales Officer Chris Counahan shares his advice to help home improvement companies grow in 2024 for Pro Remodeler's Thought Leader predictions series

Improving Processes Is the Key to Contractor Success in 2024

Florida Window & Door president shares his expert predictions and insights on challenges facing home improvement companies in 2024 for Pro Remodeler's Thought Leader predictions series

A New Kind of Contractor Consultant

Briana Hetherington uses a culture and connection approach to help home improvement companies fulfill their potential

Jericho Home Improvements CEO Killed in Kansas City

John Bartrom founded the largest independent kitchen and bath remodeling company in the country


Stop Leads Slipping Through Cracks: Close More Deals with Builder Prime

The only “Does-It-All” CRM built specifically for remodeling and home improvement contractors.  

4 Surprising Home Improvement Trends for 2024

Leaf Home CEO Jon Bostock offers insight on topics and trends that will impact the home improvement industry this year

boombox2 -
halfpage2 -
native1 -

More in Category

native2 -
halfpage1 -
leaderboard1 -