Currently Reading

Yelp and Your Online Reputation


Yelp and Your Online Reputation

Yelp lawsuit raises the question: Do online reviewers have the right to remain anonymous?

By By the Professional Remodeler staff June 3, 2015
Yelp sticker on business door.
This article first appeared in the PR May 2015 issue of Pro Remodeler.

Yelp has long been accused of extortion-like business practices, but recently, the online review site went on the defensive when a crowdfunded documentary began receiving national attention. The film, which is halfway through principal photography, claims that Yelp buries positive reviews and highlights negative ones if business owners won’t advertise with the site. Yelp officials vehemently deny the allegation. 

Billion Dollar Bully had an original goal of raising $60,000 on Kickstarter to pay for the rest of filming, but it handily surpassed that figure, with more than $90,000 donated by the end of the funding period. 

Media attention for the film affected Yelp’s shares, which were down by as much as 4 percent when news of the documentary hit. The stock has rebounded since then, and at press time was trading at 49.59. Yelp’s high was 101.75 in March of last year. 

In other Yelp news, the Virginia Supreme Court ruled in April in a closely watched case regarding a carpet-cleaning company in Springfield. 

In 2012, Hadeed Carpet Cleaning sued three Yelp users who anonymously posted negative reviews of the business. Owner, Joe Hadeed claimed that the reviews were fabricated and that he was unable to match them with any customer records. 

In the suit, the reviewers are named “John Does” and Hadeed’s attorneys subpoenaed Yelp for their real identities. Yelp refused, and two lower courts found in Hadeed’s favor, ordering Yelp to supply the information.

However, the Virginia Supreme Court reversed those decisions, stating that Yelp doesn’t have to disclose the users’ information. The reasoning was that the state’s lower courts did not have jurisdiction over Yelp—a California-based company. The justices’ decision to focus their ruling on jurisdictions rather than Hadeed’s actual argument leaves an important legal question unanswered: Do online reviewers have the right to remain anonymous in this case? PR

Yelp lawsuit raises the question: Do online reviewers have the right to remain anonymous?


Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Related Stories

3 Areas Successful Remodelers Focus On

Industry advisor Mark Richardson shares what separates the losing from the winning in today’s market

Is SEO Dead?

Industry leaders weigh in on evolving your home improvement marketing

Peppermill Finish

New for 2024, Peppermill brings a darker brown with a grey undertone to the table that coordinates well with lighter colors. This gorgeous stain adds…

Pro Remodeler’s 2024 Pinnacle Experience Reaches New Heights

The sold-out event covered leadership, lead gen, sales, and technology

Brian Gottlieb Receives Remodeling Mastery Award

Presented by industry icon, Mark Richardson, the award celebrated Gottlieb’s extraordinary impact on remodeling

Real AI Applications For Remodelers

Tech-forward remodeler Michael Anschel shares how he uses artificial intelligence in his business.

NARI Renames Awards Program

The awards program has a new name, but continues its tradition of recognizing the best in residential remodeling

This Contractor Gained 100,000+ Followers in One Year—Here's How

Stephanie Dailey followed one social media philosophy to hit influencer status on Instagram

6 Results-Proven Marketing and Sales Tips for Contractors

The Pinnacle Experience’s keynote speaker, author of "They Ask, You Answer" offers results-driven tips contractors can start today for improved leads

How to Get More Leads with a Stronger Remodeling Brand

Discover how to build a strong brand for your construction company, and learn key strategies to differentiate and attract better leads


More in Category