Lighting: Theory Meets Practice

Real-world footcandle readings shine a light on the importance of recessed fixture size, lamp type, and fixture location

March 02, 2018
computer lighting model

A computer lighting model converts input (such as ceiling and counter height, fixture and lamp type, surface color and reflectance, etc.) into both 2D output showing projected fc levels at every point on a 2x2 grid (above right), and a 3D model of the room showing the effects of the lighting plan (above). Current light levels at the island (right) are more than three times the 15 fc readings taken before the kitchen remodel.

In my May 2017 article, “Recessed Reconsidered,” I made the case that the conventional wisdom of laying out kitchen lighting is mostly wrong. It appears everyone is designing by eye instead of checking results, which you can easily do with a smartphone and light meter app. I had collected preliminary data for my clients’ remodel, which was ongoing at the time, and my article charted our test results with the cans located at 24, 30, 36, 42, and 48 inches out from the wall. My conclusion was that, with can lights centered more than 24 inches out from the wall, it is virtually impossible to deliver anything close to the minimum 50 footcandles NKBA recommends, particularly with a cook standing there and blocking the light.

My clients’ remodel is now complete, and I went by this summer to compare theory to reality. I also did a post-occupancy measurement of delivered footcandles (fc) on a major kitchen redo that I had modeled on computer. In both cases, the data, resoundingly supported earlier evidence-based lighting theory that the light level at the work surface depends on three factors: the fixture, the lamp, and especially the fixture location.

Mike and Holly’s Kitchen

The bungalow kitchen in my earlier article received a minor makeover—taking down the wall between kitchen and dining room, installing new countertops, and adding a bunch of can lights to supplement the lonely surface-mounted ceiling light fixture. I visited Mike and Holly a couple of months after the remodel, and while sitting in the dining room, I was bothered by glare coming from the new recessed cans in the adjacent kitchen 15 feet away. I also noticed that the light quality was bland, without any highlights.

Before and after photos show how light levels in this Denver bungalow remodel by Parkside Remodeling and Doug Walter Architects were vastly improved by removing the wall between the existing kitchen and the family room, and installing a completely new lighting scheme.

Taking out my light meter, I found that the lamps the electrician had installed were only delivering 15 fc to the work surface, far below what I had planned. He’d substituted BR30 floods for the PAR30 floods I’d specified, probably because they were cheaper and more readily available.  Luckily, I had a case of PAR30’s in my car, and when I installed them and took another meter reading, it showed 158 fc on the counters! Same lumens (900), same wattage (11), but 10 times the delivered footcandles! Plus, the quality of light was much more pleasant, with very little glare and more of a difference between the counters and the walls.

Do Mike and Holly run their cans at 158fc? I doubt it—that’s what dimmers are for—but it’s nice to have it when you need it. Is 158 fc too much? Not when you compare it to daylight pouring in through the windows.

I repeated my lamp and fixture location experiments at another ongoing remodeling project with the help of my colleague Jeni Finnigan, an occupational therapist with an interest in home modification around lighting. After hearing about the relamping at Mike and Holly’s, she decided to relamp the cans in her own kitchen. The results (see “PAR Instead of BR,” above), show “before” light meter readings with BR30 floods and “after” readings with PAR30 floods that are three to five times higher. Though not as dramatic as Mike and Holly’s results, the layout of lights in Jeni’s kitchen is not ideal and in many locations you work in your own shadow. We discussed further improvements, such as the undercabinet LED tape light she installed to the left of the sink, which by itself adds 10 fc.

Location Matters

Bulb type can obviously make a huge difference in how much light actually makes it to the surface of a kitchen countertop, but even the biggest brightest bulb can be ineffective if the fixture isn’t properly located. After changing the bulbs in Jen’s kitchen, when I took measurements while she was standing at the counter my readings returned to their original levels—12 fc at the range and 8 fc to the left of the sink.

The tracing (see “Typical Textbook Lighting Design,” below) is typical of what kitchen designers find in lighting textbooks. I scaled the drawing, assuming the edge of the countertop is at 25 inches, and found that the can lights are located more than 50 inches from the wall—well beyond the 24 inches my research indicates is ideal. 

To confirm my theory, I took before and after measurements on several subsequent remodeling projects, which gave me comparative data on light levels under real-world conditions. In one project, the data clearly show that relocating the cans to 24 inches yielded the best results by far in the situation that matters most—when a cook is standing at the counter (see, “Right Fixture, Right Location,” above right).

A second, much larger project confirmed these results, and also gave me an opportunity to compare light levels as predicted by computer modeling with actual light levels measured at project completion (see “Theory vs. Practice,” below right). In this case, the original lighting plan was an almost mathematical grid of 6-inch cans equipped with BR38 lamps that generated an average of about 15 fc at the countertops. After redesigning the kitchen, including the island, we created a new lighting plan that called for 5-Inch cans with PAR30 floods. The results are pretty convincing, although I was only able to achieve 70 fc at the island. I plan to swap in S or NS (spot or narrow spot) lamps in this location to see if they will boost light levels nearer to my goal of 100 fc. 

Now What?

There is still work to be done. For instance, my experience has been that  3- and 4-inch-diameter cans can’t deliver the lighting levels I want, so I have been using 5-inch cans in 8-foot ceilings. Recently, however, I have learned that dedicated LED light engines put out a lot more punch than medium-base fixtures equipped with screw-in LED bulbs, and also have double the lamp life. I am planning to gather data from working jobsites using smaller-diameter cans and various lens combinations to see what’s possible. 

I am also currently collecting data to document the effects of layered light. But the point of all this is to show that good lighting design is neither art nor science, but a combination of both. Design-by-the-numbers alone won’t consistently create light levels that positively affect mood and well-being; good lighting design still requires an artist’s touch.

About the Author


About the Author


Doug Walter, of Doug Walter Architects, in Denver, has specialized in residential remodeling for 25 years. He has a long history with Universal Design and aging in place. He helped write the NAHB’s Certified Aging-in-Place Specialist curriculum and holds an ICC Certificate as an Accessibility Inspector.

Comments

Comments

Just read your article and do not understand how your credentials match. In nearly every kitchen I do ( and have done so without the customer actually knowing it was coming) under-cabinet lighting is installed. It adds minimal cost, and the results are outstanding. A 20" LED strip per 30" of upper cabinet is the rule, and practically eliminates shadows from primary lighting. I often have switch boxes wired so the under-cabinet lights are the primary lighting for the kitchen, with the (otherwise primary lighting) switched as secondary ( i have the wires installed so that option is available to change at any time) . In showroom type kitchens, okay whats the point, but for families - i.e. getting up in the middle of the night, coming home late, etc. etc., a bright light in the kitchen not only isn't necessary, it's often unappreciated. Yet all the light needed is there in a soft nuanced sort of way. Think about it, and send me my royalties, my retirement fund could use it.

Kudos to you for making undercabinet lights part of your standard package. They are indeed an important part of a well -lit kitchen. Sorry I won't be sending along any "royalties" because undercabinets alone don't do it. Most off the shelf LED units you buy (lensed or tape) put down at best 15 to 20 foot candles out near the front of the counters; I've measured. You CAN specify high output fixtures with around 400 lumens per foot that can get footcandles up to 45, just a whisker shy of the NKBA and IES recommended 50 foot candles on counters.
I have a client who told me last week he almost never runs his undercabinet lights. Why? They run too hot; they were the old Xenon lights we used to use, as they were the best you could get. Unfortunately they run incredibly HOT, like 400 degrees. I'm going over some night this week to measure both temperature and light levels, and suggest LED retrofits to him.
Undercabinet lights are just one of several layers I recommend for kitchens that includes recessed can task lighting and decorative/ambient light fixtures. All three types of lighting should be on dimmers , to give the homeowner maximum control for the time of day, the task, the user.
I'd urge you to put a free light meter app on your phone and check light levels in your kitchens with undercabinets only, undercabinets and overheads. You may be surprised. Several existing kitchens I measured recently prior to remodeling measured 15 foot candles with every light blazing at full strength. Remember, 50 fc is the recommended minimum, especially for seniors and the low vision population.
Thanks so much for reading the article and being so engaged!

kschuler's picture

Editor's note: We received this question via email from Jessica Webber. 

I enjoyed your article. As a kitchen and bath designer and remodeler, I feel like I am constantly educating homeowners on the need for and the proper use of light. Would you mind sharing the light measuring apps you use that are your favorites?

 

kschuler's picture

Editor's noteThis response was written by the author of this article, Doug Walter, via email. 

Sure, happy to share: I use two on my Android phone: Light Companion and Light Meter Pro. Both were free. If you have an Apple device, go to the Apple store and search for light meters; you don’t want the ones for photographers that tell you fstops, you want one that measures in foot candles and lux. Lux is the European standard, and one foot candle equals 10.76 lux. Some measure only in lux, but who wants to do that much math?

Using the light meter app will change the way you design; it certainly did for me.

kschuler's picture

Editor's note: We received this question via email from Nick Calvillo.

I work for a remodeling company out in Kansas City, and we have been struggling with lighting design. I found your lighting technique very interesting as it does contradict a lot of what I have been taught. We are wanting to show the 'throw' of the can lights on our plans so that the homeowners can see how each light affects the space, but I have been struggling trying to find this information. 

Is there a good resource for me to use, either as research or as a tool, to accurately and effectively design lighting? We currently use Chief Architect to design, and the lighting tools are not very accurate. Let me know if you have any suggestions, thank you.

kschuler's picture

Editor's note: This response was written by the author of this article, Doug Walter.

Thank you for the feedback; I’m glad you found the article useful. Please look up my previous articles in ProRemodeler, too, about lighting. Erika Taylor’s editorial (in the March issue) names a couple. I know of no text that teaches this, but there are plenty of good lighting resource texts—I’ve attached a bibliography. I particularly like Randall Whitehead’s books.

The takeaway from my article is that you may want to do what I did—your own low-budget lighting research. Start with the current or last project you did. Download a free light meter app or buy an inexpensive light meter, and go over one evening and measure delivered footcandles at the countertops after turning on all lights. Do you have at least 50 fc? Then you’re doing great.

If you’re like me, you have your “go-to” fixtures and lamps that you use job after job. You owe it to the customers to know what those fixtures do in different situations (8-foot vs. 10-foot ceilings, for example). If your go-to fixture doesn’t cut it, experiment with different lamps, as I mention in several articles, until you get there. For example, in an older remodel, the client called me to consult on upgrading the lighting. He had bought 800-lumen LED BR30s, but when I measured delivered footcandles, they were a paltry 12 fc. I went out to my car and brought in a 1100-lumen LED PAR 30 NFL, and we got 257 fc!

There may well be good lighting layout software, but I don’t use it. Much of the software is geared to commercial lighting layouts that are normally in a grid and designed to deliver an average level of footcandles in the entire space, usually 30 fc in offices. In kitchens we want the useable light on the counters, and the spill light in the walkways. If it’s a large kitchen, you may drop a recessed can in those areas to make sure they’re bright enough.

Good luck!

kschuler's picture

Editor's note: We received this question via email from Mark Leas.

Just finished reading your excellent article in Pro Remodeler. Thanks for sharing that!

Which light meter app do you suggest that I download so that I can apply what I have just learned?

kschuler's picture

Editor's note: This response was written by the author of this article, Doug Walter.

Thank you for the feedback! I hope you are inspired to start checking your prior and current work; it sounds like you are, given your request. If you have a kitchen that is already roughed in, you can have your sparky power up that circuit so you can check it before the drywall makes it much harder to move lights!

Yes, for my Android, I have two free apps: Light Companion and Light Meter Pro. I’ve checked them against my “real” light meters, and they compare well. For super critical jobs, I use the actual light meters. Today, the cost is down to less than $50. Good luck!

Thank you for all the kitchen lighting research you have done and shared. I am a landscape architect currently in the design phase of a kitchen re-model and your comments have been incredibly helpful.

Reading this article, what constitutes a "dedicated LED light engine"? I am guessing this is a fixture with the LED lamp built in, not a fixture which accepts an LED lamp?

Yes, I am differentiating between housings that come without the bulb in them, and the ones that have the LED built into them. I haven't tested any of those type fixtures yet, but am anxious to , from what outputs I saw at the IBS/KBIS show in Orlando in January. The dedicated fixtures seemed to outperform the ones I've been testing with the interchangeable bulbs.

Add new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
Overlay Init