Building Things Right: Finished Basement

The dos and don’ts for properly finishing a basement

December 07, 2015
Waterproofing dos and don'ts to ensure a dry basement

For years—decades, really—the entire building science community has been working to improve the way we build and remodel. Everyone has been testing and publishing and lecturing … and yet there is still so much resistance to building things right. Why is that?

We think it’s partly because people are busy, change takes time, and time is precious. The architect is too busy to redraw the section; the contractor doesn’t know what’s missing; the crew can’t install it correctly without instructions; and instructions are boring, or poorly written, or both.

So here’s the solution: At Otogawa-Anschel Design+Build we’ve picked five house components that every remodeler has to mess with, and we’re going to cover them in a series of articles in this section. For each one, we’re collaborating with Professional Remodeler’s editors to provide detailed drawings, the dos and don’ts behind those details, plus online videos and animations that walk you step-by-step through proper installation. What you gain is everything you need to get the job done right; what you lose are your excuses for doing it the wrong way.

Basements Are Wet

Let’s start with the basement. Unless it’s built like a boat, with proper exterior waterproofing and radon control systems in place, a basement is a dangerous space to finish. The ground around a basement is almost always wet, and the walls and concrete slab are porous; CMUs and mortar joints are super-porous. A basement may look dry, but that’s because the walls and floor are being heated, converting liquid water into vapor, which is pulled into the air. As soon as you cover up those surfaces and insulate, which restricts air flow and moves the condensation point to the interior surface of the foundation wall, you’ll have wet walls and floors.

A basement should be built like a boat to keep water out. But most houses are built on porous walls and floors with nothing between the wet and the dry. In a house that is built like a sieve, if you want finish materials in the basement, you first have to manage the moisture in the walls and floor. To be successful, there are a few simple things you absolutely must do, and a few you absolutely must avoid. 

Here’s a list of Dos and Don’ts, plus some illustrations that show everything you need. 


DO install a drain-tile system with a sump pump that discharges any water within a minimum of 5 feet from the foundation. 

DO extend interior drain board from the drain tile up to at least 6 inches above grade. Best is a dimpled sheathing such as Cosella-Dorken's Delta-Dry


DO frame with steel studs set on a capillary break, such as a sill seal (this also helps with uneven floors).

DO hold framing 1 inch away from the foundation walls—no exceptions!

DO spray high-density polyurethane foam 2 to 3 inches thick behind the stud wall and all the way up onto the rim joist. If you choose to use batt insulation, don’t let it touch the foundation walls.

DO install paperless drywall, such as DensGlass, and hold it ½ inch off the floor. 

DON’T let the wall framing touch the walls or the floor (treated lumber wicks water).


DO use moisture-resistant flooring, such as ceramic tile or vinyl composition tile. If you want the look of wood, cover the slab with a vapor-control layer with taped seams and install a glued or dry-fit engineered click-lock floating floor system. 

DON’T install carpet.


How to finish a basement properly


For a PDF and animated version of this detail, see “Details for Warm and Dry Basement Living Space” at


Michael Anschel is president of Otogawa-Anschel Design + Build, in Minneapolis, and a founding board member of Greenstar.

About the Author



Why are my ways that I have lived by for about 30 years--that other builders have told me I was wrong in my ways--finally being accepted? Problems are, I have used other approaches that have worked perfectly. Others are taking credit for my tried and true ways of keeping water and moisture out of below-grade finished living spaces. Jeff Koerner.


Sounds like your clients benefited from your forward thinking! I don't claim to have invented this sytem. I'm simply giving it my stamp of approval and encouraging the industry to make it their standard basement finish detail. Like you said, this system works.



I used to use metal studs until I found a better way to do basement walls. Check out Wahoo Walls. This system gives continuous insulation and eliminates metal that rusts and corrodes, and it reduces mold and mildew issues at the same time and can withstand minor flooding issues. Check it out

Otherwise great advice and what we preach as well.

Bob Williams Star Construction Company, West Newbury, MA


Thanks for reading this and commenting and mostly agreeing! It has been a while! So, the sil seal that we install between concrete and metal studs ensures no moisture gets to our metal. Even if they were to get wet, I'd rather have rust than rot and mildew. The sil seal goes under all base plates, not just the exterior wall. 

I looked at the wahoo wall website and from what I can tell it is a pannelized system, which could work well for newer homes, but in older homes I can't see a panelized solution working very well. Too many irregularities in the foundation, pipes in the ceiling, and wouldn't let me throw in any of my signature curved walls!

Glad to hear we agree on the dimple board tied into the drain tile though. Truthfully, that is the critical detail!

Thanks, Bob!

Add new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
Overlay Init