The leading case on this issue comes out of New York. A surveyor prepared a site plan for the construction of a new building. The plan consisted of a depiction of the grade, land contours, and a proposed location for the building and utilities. During construction, the original surveyor was terminated and an amended survey plan was used. The new plan was substantially similar to the original, prompting the first surveyor to file a copyright infringement suit.
The district court found that the site plan was not copyrightable and noted that the identification of existing physical characteristics of the site, such as elevation measurements and location of boundaries, are not afforded copyright protection.
But the appellate court vacated the district court’s decision, noting that—along with the existing physical characteristics of the site, which do not contain any originality on the part of the author—the original survey plans also contained detailed specifications for the improvement of the site, and these were entitled to copyright protection.
Based on this ruling, merely identifying existing factual information about the site—abutting parcels, public streets, elevations, and existing structures—wouldn’t be copyrightable. However, detailed specifications for the preparation and improvement of the site showing original and creative authorship would be entitled to copyright protection.
This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice.
Related Stories
Tips to Get Started on Your Exit Strategy
It’s never too early to begin planning the next stage of your life. Industry advisor Mark Richardson offers some tips to get started
The Pinnacle Experience Delivers the Must-Attend Event of 2022
The happening unveils a fresh, innovative format ensuring more value, excitement, knowledge, and fun – but none of what is boring about conventional-style conventions.
Are You a Farmer or a Hunter?
Industry advisor Mark Richardson says that over the last year, there’s been a major shift in the remodeling business from a farming mentality to a hunting skill set
A Stressful Purchase: Remodeling in Times of Uncertainty
How should remodelers react to anxious consumers? Director of Content Erika Mosse shares her experience
The Argument for a Four Day Remodeling Work Week
The four-day work week has a global spotlight—could it work in remodeling?
How We Nurture Trade Partner Relationships
Here's what the director of production of a $36 million company does to strengthen trade partner relationships
5 Client Red Flags to Watch
Using these guidelines in the first meeting can save a lot of time and energy down the road
How to Master the Art of Language in Remodeling Sales
Mark Richardson says it's a remodeler's obligation to communicate, not your client, trade partner, or team's responsibility to understand
Stepping Back: Selling My Company to Employees
A remodeler shares the details of selling his company to two employees
10 Tips for Transitioning Out of Your Business
On this episode of Remodeling Mastery, host and industry advisor Mark Richardson dives into what to consider as remodelers plan their exit