A study conducted by researchers from UC Berkeley and the University of Chicago found that energy-efficient updates in Michigan homes supported by the Federal Weatherization Assistance didn’t pay off financially.
(A summary of the study appears in the UChicago News; the original document can be downloaded from the Social Science Research Network.)
The retrofit only delivered “a small fraction of their promised energy savings and [they] may not save any money over the long run,” AZ Central reports. Updates included the installation of new windows and high-efficiency HVAC systems, which did cut a home’s energy consumption as well as the homeowner’s bills, just not enough to cover the installation costs
The study used data from a random sample of 30,000 low-income Michigan households that were eligible for an Energy Department home weatherization program.
In Construction Dive’s summary of the report, researchers found that “the homes in the study had been retrofitted with $5,100 worth of energy upgrades. Over the lifetime of the upgrades, the households had saved an average of $2,400 — less than half the price of the improvements.”
Researchers say that the study should not be seen as a dismissal of energy-efficient weatherization methods in general.
“The study, which encompassed about 30,000 homes, targets a small subset of income-eligible homes in a very cold state. You can't extrapolate that to all energy efficiency, or even all weatherization,” Meredith Fowlie, associate professor at UC Berkeley and lead author of the study, told Utility Dive. She also cautions that trying to toss out the results because they contradict so many other studies “would also be incorrect.”
Related Stories
Working Toward Affordable, Resilient Homes
A new natural disaster protection act from NAHB aims to support hazard mitigation projects
Client Design Choices in the Time of Social Media and AI
Social media speeds up the trend cycles, and now artificially created images are falling into homeowners' hands
Indoor Air Quality Gets Smart
A home's air quality can now be cloud connected and fully automated with this innovative product
Webinar: From Disjointed Design to Cohesive and Efficient—The New American Remodel 2023
Access the recording for the first The New American Remodel webinar held on March 8 at 2 pm CT
5 Standout Energy-Efficient Products Spotted at IBS 2023
See what this green remodeler recommends from the show floor
Innovative Products: GAF Energy Timberline Solar Shingles
GAF Energy’s latest innovation has taken the solar world by storm
Detailed Design: Benefits of Biophilism
See the details our Model ReModel contractors chose to infuse nature into their ADU
Heat Pumps Now Required in Washington New Construction
Washington is the second state to require heat pumps in an effort to electrify homes