flexiblefullpage - default
interstitial1 - interstitial
Currently Reading

A Classic—or a Classic Problem?

Advertisement
billboard -
Design

A Classic—or a Classic Problem?

Remodelers and builders who want to be proficient in their craft should understand the designs they imitate


October 26, 2016
This article first appeared in the November 2016 issue of Pro Remodeler.

Last year, a spec home went up on my block. It’s Georgian, about 4,000 square feet, and the original asking price was just over $1 million. The builder is a nice guy with a background in remodeling and I believe he honestly wanted to create a beautiful home. 

But that hasn’t worked out so well.

To date, the house has gone through three price reductions and is still sitting there like a lonely kid nobody wants at their birthday party. There are many reasons for this—a lousy floor plan, no backyard, a footprint much too big for the lot—but there’s another more subtle factor at work that’s also important. 

The house looks wrong. That’s the only way to describe it; there’s something that just doesn’t appeal to the eye. Recently I had the privilege of interviewing Brent Hull, owner of Hull Historical, in Fort Worth, Texas, for a profile in Professional Remodeler next month. Hull is an expert in historical design, and I showed him a photo of the home in question. He shook his head sadly.

“This guy is trying,” Hull said, “but he doesn’t understand the fundamentals of classical design.” Hull went on to make a bold claim: “I suspect this builder saw a house that he really loved on Swiss Avenue [historic district in Dallas] and thought he was replicating it here. The problem is that he doesn’t know what he’s doing.” 

That evening, I went on Google maps and took a look down Swiss Avenue. I didn’t think I’d find the actual house, but the idea of it intrigued me. 

Lo and behold, the house was there. 

The second I saw it, I understood exactly what the builder/remodeler was trying to accomplish on my block and also precisely where he fell heartbreakingly short. The two homes, built about 100 years apart, are nearly identical. Yet the tiny areas where they differ make one stately and graceful and the other disproportional and claustrophobic. Such small things: the choice of an arch rather than a straight edge, the size of a column as it relates to the molding and bands above it, the pattern of the bricks. 

The root of the problem lies not with this particular house but with a professional who has no education in classical architecture and its place in the larger narrative of home design. Hull talks about this constantly, and I now see the seriousness of the issue as well. As long as remodelers and builders lack an understanding of the designs they are imitating, they will never be proficient, or even reliable, in their craft.

Tags


written by

Erika Mosse

Director of Content

Erika Mosse is the director of content for Professional Remodeler. Contact her at emosse@sgcmail.com or 972.369.9212.

leaderboard2 - default

Related Stories

Marvin Releases Switchable Privacy Glass Window

The privacy glass windows can be purchased from Marvin's Direct Glaze windows

Building A Small Projects Division from the Ground Up

Through hard work and careful strategy, Harth Home Services has seen big growth

Client Design Choices in the Time of Social Media and AI

Social media speeds up the trend cycles, and now artificially created images are falling into homeowners' hands

Design Trends to Watch in 2024

What’s in and out for the upcoming year? Remodeling designers share insights

Benjamin Moore Announces its Color of the Year 2024

Will next year be the year of blues?

Color of the Year 2024 Announced by Sherwin-Williams

The color is set to mimic ever-present peace

Insights for Designing Outdoor Kitchens

Was the pandemic-fueled thirst for outdoor kitchen remodels and additions a fluke, or is it here to stay? Plus: The top design considerations for outdoor kitchens

Home Run Remodeling Lessons: The New American Remodel 2023

A final look at The New American Remodel 2023

Webinar: From Disjointed Design to Cohesive and Efficient—The New American Remodel 2023

Access the recording for the first The New American Remodel webinar held on March 8 at 2 pm CT

4 Award-Winning Remodeling Projects to Inspire

This selection of Best in American Living Award winners showcases balancing of original character with modern-day design

Advertisement
boombox2 -
Advertisement
halfpage2 -
Advertisement
native1 -

More in Category




Advertisement
native2 -
Advertisement
halfpage1 -
Advertisement
leaderboard1 -