Director of Content

Sal Alfano is Director of Content for Professional Remodelersalfano@sgcmail.com, 202.603.4884

Inside the Circle

Why a culture of trust and information sharing trumps one of competition driven by me-first motives 

January 05, 2017

I live and work in northwest Washington, D.C., home of a pizza place called Comet Ping Pong. It’s now famous because about a month ago a 28-year-old North Carolina man armed with an assault rifle and a pistol entered the restaurant to “investigate” a story that had gone viral on social media sites in the days leading up to the presidential election. The story said that a ring of pedophiles tied to Hillary Clinton and John Podesta was holding children as sex slaves in the basement of the Comet building. After a tense 45 minutes, the suspect was arrested. No children were found in the basement. And no one was hurt.

At least not directly. But this bizarre event raises a number of troubling questions. I will leave it to others to speculate on why the conspiracy theory went viral in the first place. More important to me is the effect “fake news” has on how safe and secure people feel and on where they place their trust. 

Leadership and Company Culture

By coincidence, at the time of the Comet Ping Pong event I was reading Leaders Eat Last, a book by Simon Sinek in which he discusses how people working under leaders who create a “circle of safety” are more likely to support and help coworkers instead of looking out for themselves at the expense of others. This leads to sharing of information instead of hoarding it, greater accountability and less fear about making mistakes, and more behavior that is other-directed instead of me-first, all of which contribute to a stronger business that better serves its employees and its customers.

In one of many examples. Sinek looks at Jack Welch, who as CEO of GE during the 1980s and ’90s earned the nickname “Neuron Jack” for his tactic of rewarding the top-performing 20 percent of his employees and firing the bottom 10 percent every year. It led to spectacular success for GE and its shareholders, and celebrity status for Welch. But it created a culture of competition, backbiting, and selfishness that eventually led to steep declines in profitability, especially in times of stress, such as the post-9/11 economy and post-2007 Great Recession.

By contrast, Sinek presents James Sinegal, the co-founder of Costco. He believed in treating employees like family and backed that up with actions that protected his workforce. During the Great Recession, he increased wages and refused to cut benefits because he realized his employees needed more, not less, to get through hard times.

Costco went public in 1986 and if you had bought its stock and GE’s back then, Sinek points out, by 2013 your ROI on the GE stock would have been 600 percent, about the same as the S&P 500. The ROI for Costco over the same period? 1,200 percent. Although at one point the GE investment could have yielded a 1,600 percent return, timing the cash-out was what Sinek calls a “roller coaster” ride. Costco’s return, by contrast, rose slowly but steadily over the entire period.

Circle of Safety

As Sinek says, we can rely on rules and technology, but we can only trust people. With the rise of fake news and the portent of more events like those at Comet, and all of the insecurity that creates in the personal lives of employees and customers, your business needs a circle of safety now more than ever. For Sinek, that means giving authority to the people who are closest to the information, creating an environment where it is safe to make mistakes, and encouraging people to share ideas without having to worry about being one-upped.

As the leader, you’re in the center of a circle of safety that only you can draw.  

Looking for more info on leadership? Watch this TED Talk, “Why Good Leaders Make You Feel Safe.”

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
Overlay Init